a conservative heretic commenting on hypocrisy and stupidity in a world with too much of both
If you found this post of interest, please share it with your friends.
We no longer accept advertising on this blog. Your donations help us to defray the costs of its operation and are much appreciated.
Stay informed

Follow the Bear - Subscribe today


Albertans Have Reclaimed Their Democracy

He was the White Knight that would save the Party; a Conservative Justin Trudeau, the anointed one and potentially the heir apparent to Stephen Harper. He parachuted into provincial politics from his high-paying banking position with all of the confidence that only a virtual guarantee of success can provide and it only took Jim Prentice eleven months to screw that up.

He was the Cool Hand Luke of Canadian politics; good looking, smooth and oh so very confident. Unfortunately, he not only started to read his own press clippings – he started to believe them.

He was so confident and smooth, in fact, that after winning a seat to sit in the legislature as the newly anointed premier, he set about to destroy an opposition that was already too small and too weak to really do much damage to his future.

It was an unnecessary display of cynical politics that served no useful purpose for his party or the province.

With more than a little help from people like Preston Manning, Jim Prentice convinced Danielle Smith to resign her position as leader of the Wildrose Party and cross the floor to join the Conservatives. She dragged nine other party members with her which decimated Wildrose, leaving them with only 9 seats in the legislature at dissolution.

Nobody – not Jim Prentice, not Danielle Smith, not even that would-be champion of the democratic process Preston Manning – gave a tinker’s damn about democracy. The people of Smith’s riding were given the finger. The people who supported her and her party across the province were flipped the bird.

Self-interest was calling and the very clever brain trust that was running Conservative politics in Alberta answered the call.

It was that one moment, more than any other that I believe led to yesterday’s electoral defeat of the Conservative government.

Karma’s a bitch.

Even Albertans who didn’t support Wildrose or live in Smith’s riding were incensed and everything after that, from Prentice’s careless ‘look in the mirror’ comment the fumbling of his first provincial budget, was seen through the lens of that naked display of self-serving politics that ignored fundamental democratic values.

As a result, Danielle Smith who was promised a cabinet position, failed to win the nomination for the Conservatives in her former riding and now Jim Prentice is following her down the same road to political obscurity.

Albertans are unique in this country. They are individualists who aren’t shy about stating their opinions or standing up for what they believe. I know this from personal experience on the blog and more than one of my Alberta readers has put me in my place when they didn’t agree with me.

Opinionated they may be but they are also people with strong values and those values haven’t changed as a result of the election. Alberta remains a province where the majority of people embrace conservative values including small government that respects the democratic expression of the people.

Unlike Ontario, for example, which still tends to vote based on fear of the unknown or the promises of entitlements, Albertans demonstrated yesterday that as loyal to a governing party as they may be, they will step into the great beyond if they believe it is the only way to keep government a servant of the people.

Too many political parties have it backwards these days. They see the people as servants of their political ambitions; something to be manipulated in order to obtain or maintain power. The Conservatives in Alberta had evolved – or degenerated – into just one more of those parties and the people of Alberta said, “Adios” and tossed the Conservative government out on its ear.

The Conservatives didn’t merely lose the election – the party was all but destroyed. In the aftermath, Jim Prentice has resigned as Leader, resigned his seat in the legislature and is now following Danielle Smith down the road to anonymity that they built together with their political cynicism.

The Alberta election is over and the media clichés and spin have begun. It has become as much a part of politics as – well – politics but underneath the political campaigning, the polling, and the constant media jibber-jabber is one undeniable fact. Elections are about the people and when the people decide to vote in favour of defending their democracy rather than a particular party, the people win.

Partisanship, like that which we see in Ontario and countless other provinces, including briefly in Alberta when the people supported the growing cronyism of the Conservatives under Ed Stelmach and Allison Redford, is detrimental to democracy. It turns the democratic process into little more than a competition for votes rather than a debate about ideas and vision.

Under increasingly poor leadership, the Conservative party began moving away from the values of the people that supported it and the Prentice move against Wildrose, merely served to confirm just how far.

In Alberta, perhaps more than any other part of Canada, government by the people for the people has real meaning and the people spoke loud and clear yesterday. They fired the Conservative government and have appointed a new one.

It does not mean that Alberta is now socialist. It doesn’t mean that the people of Alberta have lost their minds. It simply means that the majority of people in Alberta have had enough of cynical politics and have taken back their government.

Good for them.

Hopefully the rest of us across this country will learn from yesterday’s example in Alberta and start standing up for our democratic values and principles rather than clinging to blind partisanship that forces us to rationalize in those we support what we condemn in those we oppose.

It remains to be seen if Rachel Notley, the incoming Premier can deliver what the people have voted for and I would suggest that she is on a very short leash. Four years isn’t very long and the people of Alberta will be watching. Pull a Jim Prentice or an Allyson Redford, Danielle Smith or Ed Stelmach and she too will be wandering the invisible road to obscurity after the next election.

It has fallen out of fashion in recent times but politicians would do well to seriously consider the message sent by Albertans yesterday.

Ultimately, the power of government rests with the people – not politicians and when the people finally stand up and speak, politicians had better start listening.

Partisanship and cheap political cynicism have a shorter shelf life than democracy.

Rock on Alberta!


© 2015 Maggie’s Bear

all rights reserved The written content of this article is the sole property of Maggie’s Bear but a link to it may be shared by those who think it might be of interest to others

Twitter: @maggsbear – Facebook: Maggie’s Bear  – ivmaki@sympatico.ca


  • Margie

    The unfortunate result of this election was that some very excellent people lost their seats just because they were NOT NDP candidates. The downside of democracy seems to be the party system.

    • MaggiesBear

      It isn’t just well-intentioned, hard-working representatives lose their seats when the leadership wanders away from and ignores principle and integrity. It’s also the party and by extension, the people. The Conservative movement in Canada is being seriously undermined by the recent crop of leaders both provincially and federally and those of us who believe in conservative values will pay for it for a very long time.

  • Anon

    Prentice was at least somewhat honest about Alberta’s spending problem, and made the mistake of talking wage freezes and closing agencies. The publicly employed duly punished him for his honesty by stampeding to the NDP. Couple that with Alberta filling up with non-conservative voters from other failed provinces, and the place is sadly turning into just another progressive dump.

    • MaggiesBear

      Considering the size of the public sector in Alberta, I think it’s a bit of stretch to suggest that they were responsible for the defeat of the PCs. The Conservatives have been in trouble since Ed Stelmach.

  • FPR

    I think you are correct in stating that Rachel Notley will be on a short leash. The WR will try to keep the NDP honest and on a somewhat conservative path thru the media. Although the ND know what side their bread is buttered on(unions, govt workers) they can’t afford to alienate the oil sector, agriculture or private business in general. Any downturn in the Alberta economy as a result of ND socialist policy or excessive taxation will result in the NDP being one hit wonders in 4 years.

    • MaggiesBear

      As it should be. I think all governments regardless of political affiliation should be on very short leashes and that voters should cast off partisanship and start demanding more respect and accountability from whichever party is in office.

  • Pingback: Albertans Have Reclaimed Their Democracy | Grumpy Opinions()

  • Bert_1

    Very well stated. But, I would like to make one correction: You refer to the PC’s as “The Conservatives”. That is incorrect. They are, and have been for many, many years now, politically, sociologically, economically and ideologically “The Progressives”.

    Oddly, in a perverted sort of way, I believe that that will be the salvation of our province. The NDP is no different than the PC’s they ousted.

    • MaggiesBear

      I agree with you on both counts. The reality is that for decades, there has been little difference between the Conservatives and Liberals in this country. They talk left and right but they govern from the centre. It’s why I believe we should stop being partisan and start holding political parties to account. Partisanship is killing Ontario and I admire and respect the people of Alberta for setting a standard that the rest of the country should emulate.