a conservative heretic commenting on hypocrisy and stupidity in a world with too much of both
If you found this post of interest, please share it with your friends.
We no longer accept advertising on this blog. Your donations help us to defray the costs of its operation and are much appreciated.
Stay informed

Follow the Bear - Subscribe today


Demanding for Ukrainians What is Denied to Canadians

student-vote-democracy-word-cloudThe Harper government has introduced a significant piece of legislation to address issues with elections in Canada. Called the Fair Elections Act, the legislation is more than 200 pages in length and contains some serious changes, some of which go to the heart of our constitutional rights as citizens.

One proposed change is to take away the right to vote from any Canadian citizen who lives outside of the country for five years or more. To my way of thinking this is more than simply administrative reform. This takes away a right of citizenship and, in fact, will create classes of citizenship where some have more or less rights than others.

That’s merely my opinion and others may hold differing positions but it is an issue and a proposed legislation that is serious enough that Canadians from all sides of the political spectrum should be permitted to have some input into whether or not they agree with all provisions of the bill.

The opposition parties wanted the Parliamentary committee examining the legislation to travel across Canada to meet with Canadians and give them that opportunity. The Harper government has vetoed that consultation under the guise that it is too expensive as if money was more important than our rights.

There is something patently offensive about a government that not only refuses to consult with citizens on significant changes to their rights but makes a mockery of that decision in Parliament and the media.

This morning it was announced that the Harper government would provide money to Ukraine which is in the throes of political upheaval. I support Ukrainians in their fight for more democratic reform and even support providing financial aid but what angers me is that while we have money to support Ukrainians, we don’t have money to allow Canadians to meet with a Parliamentary committee reviewing the Fair Elections Act.

We had a few million to scatter around the Middle East while the Prime Minister was in Israel but two months of across Canada Parliamentary hearings will break the bank apparently.

We have provided money to support Afghanistan, Libya, Iraq, the opposition to the Assad regime in Syria but can’t find $2 or $300,000 to meet with Canadians on democratic reform.

There is even $600,000 set aside by the Harper government to fund various Parliamentary committees to travel to Texas and New York to talk to Americans but we can’t afford to have representatives from our own government travel across this country to listen to us.

It’s not surprising when you consider this government’s track record at assessing what is and isn’t important.

Nine veterans’ service centres were closed to save $34 million but there is up to $50 million to build a new memorial to honour those same veterans. There was $100 million to squander on advertising for the Harper government’s Economic Action Plan and millions more last year to advertise the non-existent Canada Works program which still hasn’t been initiated.

There’s half a billion set aside to give to Chrysler and there was another $400 million to give to the profitable petroleum industry.

There’s lots of money being thrown around but when it comes to providing the means to allow Canadians the opportunity to speak – we’re broke. Nothing is decided based on principle; only on what is politically expedient.

Stephen Harper loves democracy and is a great supporter of it – everywhere but here in Canada. Here, he finds the whole democracy thing to be inconvenient and too expensive. He would prefer that we just sat quietly and allowed him to get on with things but that ain’t how it works.

This government wasn’t given a mandate by the people to set up classes of citizenship by unilaterally stripping away rights from some citizens. We have a right to have our thoughts heard before the legislation is passed and the right to decide for ourselves what we are and are not prepared to give up. For it’s part, the Harper government has an absolute responsibility to enable those discussions.526184_322167784546480_288501757_n

Personally, I’m tired of people like Stephen Harper, Pauline Marois and others from various political parties treating our constitutional rights as little more than privileges that they can provide or remove at their will like parents dealing with petulant children.

Whether it is Ukraine or Canada; when it comes to democratic reform, the people have a right to voice their opinion. It is cheap and cynical politics to prance around the world making a show of supporting that principle in other countries while crying poor-mouth to justify denying it to your own citizens.

If you are prepared to demand that the citizens of other countries have a right to be consulted and heard; ignoring that same right to your own citizens is nothing short of hypocrisy.

I believe that if a political leader has no respect for the people and their rights then they can’t have any for the nation, its citizens or the democratic principles on which the nation is founded. As we have seen too often in the past, a political leader who lacks the confidence to consult with his or her own people is no leader at all.

He is, in fact, what many in other countries including Ukraine, are currently fighting against.


The Fair Elections Act doesn’t address the real problems with voting

Conservatives’ Fair Election Act proposes to eliminate Elections Canada’s abilities to run get-out-and-vote campaigns

Watch: Rick Mercer rants about the Fair Elections Act


© 2013 Maggie’s Bear

all rights reserved The written content of this article is the sole property of Maggie’s Bear but a link to it may be shared by those who think it may be of interest to others

Let’s connect on Twitter: @maggsbear or send  a  friend request on Facebook to: Maggie’s Bear


  • Brent Siddons

    So you think we should continue to cater to the Canadian’s in name only who only come out of the woodwork in time of local crisis demanding help. What is the problem with showing voter ID or allowing the opportunity to raise additional campaign funding and If you break the law you go to jail. I do not recall the liberals allowing public input when they rammed the gun registry and gay marriage through the house. Quityerbitchen.

  • Pingback: Demanding for Ukrainians What is Denied to Canadians | Grumpy Opinions()

  • chaos111_99

    As far as the Harper party is concerned the only thing I have given up is supporting and voting for them.

    • MaggiesBear

      You aren’t alone. A recent series of surveys indicated that more than 70% of Canadians do not support the conservatives.

      • chaos111_99

        I bet a lot of them are also conservatives.

        • MaggiesBear


  • matthew brandley

    The more rights they take away the less it becomes a democracy. btw regarding the Ukraine, they have instituted capital controls on all banks effective immediatly to preven any more money from entering or leaving the country

    • MaggiesBear

      I’m pretty sure they’ll be only too happy to accept any donations that flow from the EU or North America. We never learn. We took sides early in Syria only to end up supporting terrorist organizations that we are fighting in other places and we failed completely to prevent that bloodbath. Ukraine is rapidly degenerating into the very real possibility of civil war and rather than choosing sides against the Russians, we should be working together to facilitate a peaceful resolution. But. . .we never learn.