a conservative heretic commenting on hypocrisy and stupidity in a world with too much of both
If you found this post of interest, please share it with your friends.
We no longer accept advertising on this blog. Your donations help us to defray the costs of its operation and are much appreciated.
Stay informed

Follow the Bear - Subscribe today


With The Thanks Of A Grateful Nation

War. Nobody likes it, least of all the people who have to go and fight but go they do. Most go because they consider it their duty to serve their country. Some never return from war, some return wounded. All who survive and who do return come home changed by the sheer brutality of the experience.

Canada’s military brass and the government talk a good talk about the courage and dedication of the men and women who serve in our armed forces. They show up to greet returning coffins and even named a stretch of highway for the fallen, calling it the Highway of Heroes.

How nice.

What they don’t do is treat returning veterans with the respect and gratitude to which they are entitled after having risked their lives in defense of what these same politicians felt was important.

The Department of National Defense (DND) has gone out of its way to dismiss as unproven, the idea that Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is a real mental illness which entitles returning veterans to benefits under their healthcare and disability plan. Imagine that, these are the same men and women who have spent endless nights and days fearing that their next step might trigger a land mine or that the approaching car might have a bomb in it.

They have been caught in firefights where people they don’t know and can’t see are trying to kill them and they experience this far from their families and the normalcy of life the rest of us take for granted.Of course some of them will come home mentally wounded.

Peter McKay, the Minister of National Defense has chided the Defense Ombudsman for taking a role that was too close to that of advocate rather than mediator in disputes between DND and veterans. It isn’t hard to understand why. It is impossible to mediate when DND refuses to acknowledge a problem and is intransigent in its response to the real suffering of individual veterans and veterans issues as a whole.

Indeed, the government actually fought its veterans in court after being sued for having clawed back some of their benefits. The government has lost the first round. In other words, the courts have determined that the government’s position is quite simply wrong but they have magnanimously offered to settle the court case rather than appeal it. Settle it? That’s just another way of saying that if veterans take less than they are owed, then the government won’t drag the case out through various courts over a few more years at even greater expense.

It reminds me of the foot-dragging the government employed when it came to light that previous governments had surreptitiously used Canadian soldiers as guinea pigs in the testing of the effects of Agent Orange. When it came to light that disproportionate number of those soldiers was contracting cancer in later years and they sought compensation, the government fought the case in court in the cynical knowledge that many of the claimants would die before the case was concluded.

Two years ago, the Department of Veterans Affairs (DVA) took it upon themselves to fight the very veterans they represent to the point that they illegally accessed one particular veteran’s medical records and leaked them publicly in an attempt to embarrass him into silence. No one at DVA was fired for this incredible breach of ethics and the law.

Like many countries, Canada talks the talk but doesn’t walk the talk when it comes to the men and women who serve in our armed forces. A young soldier suffering from PTSD, and who was suicidal, was ordered back into the combat zone after only one month of treatment. The result? He committed suicide and DND dismisses any responsibility but has fought the family tooth and nail over release of documents related to their son’s case.

The Liberal Chretien government ordered support troops to Iraq during the first Gulf War. We didn’t have desert camouflage so the government sent them to a desert country disguised as trees. Fortunately, the Americans provided some desert camouflage uniforms so that our troops wouldn’t look like a forest walking down the dusty road.

The Navy’s Sea King helicopters passed their shelf life thirty years ago. The Conservative government under Brian Mulroney finally ordered replacements in the early 90s. The incoming Liberal government under Jean Chretien cancelled the order at a cost of $500 million and initiated a new procurement for helicopters.

It is now 2012. None of the replacement helicopters have been delivered and nobody in the Conservative government of Stephen Harper has a clue when they might arrive. Meanwhile, the Navy continues to repair and fly its Sea Kings which has resulted in more than one crash and the death of at least one pilot.

The situation isn’t any better in the United States.

Officials at Houston’s National Cemetery banned all religious observances at funerals and the Obama Administration was forced to reverse a decision to ban any and all religious symbols and literature in veteran’s hospitals.

Imagine the stupidity of that policy for a moment.

The government banned religious books, like the bible, from people who actually offered their lives to preserve the freedoms of the United States which includes religious freedom. That absurd policy actually meant that a Catholic veteran who was dying in hospital would not be permitted the last rites by his grateful nation.

I spent six weeks in Miami on business two years ago and was overwhelmed by the number of veterans I saw who were missing limbs and needed wheelchairs. Many of them were poorly dressed and living on social assistance in poverty. They were the forgotten, no longer of use to government and so were discarded.

Too many of our veterans find it challenging reintegrating into civilian life. They have difficulty finding meaningful employment but the bureaucrats and the politicians are far too busy to implement programs to assist them. Instead, they waffle, speak honey words while clawing back benefits and fighting in court the very men and women who served with distinction and courage.

Many of the same bureaucrats who deny the legitimacy of the effects of combat on veterans avail themselves of their benefits program to go on stress-related leave because….well….it’s just very stressful pushing paper all day and fighting citizens on behalf of the government. It makes one wonder how quick they would be to deny veterans their benefits if they were veterans returning home after having lived for months in the 24/7 stress of a combat zone. It makes you wonder how well they would hold up in Afghanistan or some other God-forsaken war zone when they can’t handle the stress of a 9-5 job downtown.

My guess is that they wouldn’t come close to meeting the standards of the men and women who have worn the uniform with courage and honour.

It is a disgrace that government doesn’t show them the honour they deserve.


© 2012 Maggie’s Bear
all rights reserved
The content of this article is the sole property of Maggie’s Bear but a link to it may be shared by those who think it may be of interest to others

Follow The Bear on Twitter: @maggsbear or connect with a friend request on Facebook: Maggie’s Bear



  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/00068077596719584731 dmorris

    Veterans in Canada have been f***ed over by the government of the day since this Country was formed.

    My Grandfather, a WW1 veteran, was one of the founders of the Royal Canadian legion, which was simply a coalition of Veteran’s organizations joined together to try to get some assistance for Veterans. Particularly F’ed over were Indian veterans, many of whom were illiterate,and weren’t aware of the few perks granted to them on return from WW 1.

    My Grandfather took particular pleasure in helping those Indian veterans to get whatever help was available, much to the chagrin of the government of the time.

    It has been a long and inglorious struggle,and no matter the political stripe of the government, veterans have always been short changed.

    Perhaps our non-commisioned soldiers should join a good,militant Union, like the UAW,or CUPE,and through them, lobby for the benefits they deserve,but rarely get.

    I don’t like Unions much, but I hate the hypocrisy of the politicians who propagandise a young person to “join up”,then dump them when they are no longer needed. If it was anybody else BUT soldiers,there would be a front page outcry,but soldiers don’t count,to the MSM.

    I imagine there’s law preventing unionization of the military, might interfere with their “patriotic duty”, doncha know,but this,and all governments deserve this to happen.

    Whatever happened to the “Cjunk” blog,which did a damned good job of exposing government callousness toward our military?

    • http://www.blogger.com/profile/16123459288721211812 Bear

      It is a disgrace particularly when you contrast the treatment of veterans suffering from PTSD with all those bureaucrats who trundle off on sick leave because they are suffering stress at their 9-5 job. Politicians from all parties are long on talk and short of delivery when it comes to veterans and, as you correctly point out, always have been. Perhaps the next time somebody throws a war, nobody should go. We’ll see how the politicians and the bureaucrats deal with that.

  • Anonymous

    there should be no dispute between dnd and the military. the whole organization should be as one, with total support for those injured mentally or physically during combat. less than that is criminal.

    • http://www.blogger.com/profile/16123459288721211812 Bear

      I absolutely agree. If you’re going to order men and women into combat at the risk of their health and their lives, you are obligated to stand up and provide any and all support they require both in the field and when they come home. Any government not prepared to meet that obligation should be run out of town.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/18058670683654112613 newcenturion

    Another great piece Bear. As a veteran suffering from PTSD I must admit that I had great doctors and counsellors; however I’ve heard of numerous horror stories from other soldiers where the system has failed them. There are some good folks on the inside trying to do the right thing, unfortuneatly, behind every good man or woman there is a bureaucrat right behind them trying to save a dime.

    • http://www.blogger.com/profile/16123459288721211812 Bear

      I appreciate that there are many on the front line who are genuinely committed to helping veterans. It’s the hypocrisy of some politicians and their faceless bureaucrats that offend me. I grew up in a military family and saw men and women for whom the words duty, honour and loyalty actually meant something. It’s a disgrace to watch government make a mockery of the commitment and courage those who the uniform bring to their profession.